Discernment Counselling
If you or your spouse/partner are considering divorce or separation but are not completely sure that’s the best path, you are likely in a tough spot. Discernment Counselling is designed for exactly this situation. It’s a chance to slowdown, take a breath, and look at your options for your marriage or long term committed partnership.
When You're Unsure Whether to Save or End Your Relationship
The reality is, not every couple comes to therapy wanting the same thing.
Sometimes one partner is keen to repair the relationship, while the other is wondering whether there is anything left to save. Traditional couples therapy often assumes both people are committed to working on the relationship, but when one or both partners are uncertain, that assumption can actually create more frustration - for the couple and the therapist.
Discernment Counselling is specifically designed for couples where one or both partners are unsure whether to continue the relationship.
Rather than asking, “How do we fix this?” or “How do we learn to communicate better?”
Discernment Counselling asks a different question:
“Should I even try to repair this relationship, or is it time to separate?”
What is Discernment Counselling?
Discernment Counselling is a short-term, intentionally structured approach that helps couples gain a clarity and confidence about the future of their relationship before making life-changing decisions.
It is not relationship therapy.
It is a process of understanding how the relationship reached this point, for you as individuals. We explore whether meaningful change feels possible, and help both partners make a thoughtful, informed decision about what comes next.
The aim is not to persuade either partner to stay or leave. Instead, it is to gain a new clarity and confidence around which path to take next. For example, do you stay with the status quo, separate, or try therapy? Because let’s be honest, all 3 paths have pros and cons when you’re in a long term committed relationship and the stakes can feel high.
Looking at these 3 realistic propositions in detail, with a properly trained counsellor, can reduce confusion, blame and impulsive (often anger driven) decision-making. In short, Discernment Counselling gives you a better chance making these big decisions effectively and with a greater awareness, understanding and intention.
Who is Discernment Counselling For?
Discernment Counselling is often appropriate when:
-
You are in a marriage or a long term committed relationship or family system.
-
One partner is leaning toward saving the relationship while the other is leaning towards leaving.
-
One or both partners feel stuck in cycles of arguing, withdrawing or living like housemates.
-
Previous couples therapy has failed because one person (or both) wasn't fully invested in the process.
-
There has been an affair and one partner doesn’t know whether recovery is possible.
-
Separation or divorce has been discussed but no clear decision has been made.
-
Children, finances or shared responsibilities are making the decision especially difficult.
-
A couple wants to avoid making a decision they may later regret.
Who is Discernment Counselling Not For?
Although Discernment Counselling can be extremely helpful, it is not suitable for every situation. It will not be appropriate where:
-
There is ongoing domestic abuse, coercive control or fear for a partner's safety.
-
The relationship is not based on a long term commitment - either marriage or a serious previous commitment to one another or a family unit.
-
One partner is unwilling to attend voluntarily.
-
There is active addiction or severe mental health difficulties that require immediate specialist treatment.
-
One partner has already made a final, irreversible decision to end the relationship and is not open to any exploration.
-
Both partners are fully committed to repairing the relationship - in this case, couples therapy is usually the better starting point.
FAQ's
How many sessions are there?
Discernment Counselling is designed to be brief, usually lasting between one and five sessions. The aim is not long-term therapy but helping couples find a new clarity and confidence about their next step. You only need t0 commit to one session at a time. For current session prices please see the specific page that lists the cost of services.
What happens during sessions?
Discernment Counselling looks very different from traditional couples therapy. Sessions usually involve meeting together as a couple, but then also having individual conversations with me in each session. We explore each person's experience of the relationship separately, looking at the patterns that have developed over time, and seek to understand each partner's contribution to those patterns. We consider whether meaningful change feels realistic and clarify hopes, fears and uncertainties you have as an individual. The focus is not on resolving arguments or teaching communication skills. Instead, the work centres on helping each person become clearer about themselves, the relationship and the decision they face.
We are not sure if Discernment Counselling is for us. How do we decide?
Discernment Counselling is designed for a very specific place in a relationship: where one partner is leaning in (wanting to repair and continue the relationship) and the other is leaning out (uncertain whether they want to stay, or thinking about leaving). It isn’t about deciding who is right or getting too much into the detail of any specific fight; it’s about gaining clarity before making a life-changing decision. A discovery call is essential to determine whether Discernment Counselling is the right approach for you. During the individual 30 minute calls, we'll explore where each partner is currently positioned and whether the process is likely to be helpful. For example, if both of you are committed to working on the relationship, couples therapy is usually a better fit. Equally, if one person has already made a firm decision to end the relationship and isn’t open to exploring it but hasn’t told the other, Discernment Counselling is unlikely to be helpful and I would be honest about that during the discovery call. If this is the situation you are in, we can discuss alternative options in your individual discovery call that may better meet your needs.
Will you tell us whether we should stay together?
No. My role is not to decide for you. Instead, I help both partners explore the relationship deeply enough so you can make your own decision with greater confidence and understanding.
What if one of us wants therapy and the other doesn't?
This is exactly the kind of situation Discernment Counselling was designed for. It provides a space where both partners' positions are respected rather than assuming that both already want to repair the relationship, which by the very nature of the work, regular couple therapy tends to assume.
What if one person decides to separate or stop before the end of the 5 sessions?
Discernment Counselling does not see any path as a failure as the goal is always and only to find a new clarity and confidence in individual choices. After engaging in the process, whether for one session or five, it is a reality that a mutual agreement may not have been reached. However, if one partner has truly decided to take the path of separation the next steps can be discussed so both parties can understand a clear way forward.
What happens if we decide to do nothing or both want to continue with the work?
You may decide to keep the status quo and not make any big decisions at this point. Sometimes, there isn’t the energy to move to separation or to do the work in couple therapy, and 'staying the course’ without making any new major commitments either way is a really valid path to take for many couples. The discernment process can help you get to that point and agree that path, but this time with intention and some agreement about what that might look like in reality. Equally, if both partners decide there is a willingness to work on the their own contribution to the relationship, we can discuss whether ongoing couples therapy is the right next step and what that process would involve.
If You Think This Process Is For You - Next Steps
Living in uncertainty can be one of the most painful places for a relationship to be. Whether you ultimately decide to stay together or separate, making that decision thoughtfully can reduce regret, minimise conflict and create a clearer path forward. If you and your partner feel stuck between staying and leaving, it may be useful to each book an initial individual consultation to see if Discernment Counselling is for you. From there you can see if a structured, compassionate space to explore your options, without pressure or judgement, is going to be the most effective next step.